I’m from the baseball and NFL section, ok, that’s how i got my Top Contributor status. I’m a runner and triathlete too
Look when some high school kid or a beginner runner comes on here asking for training advice….I see the runners with some really good tips, training schedules…almost at the level of on line coaching..that’s great.
But there’s another group here who just doesn’t have a clue but still insist to hand out advice. sometimes you are telling the kid.."just do what I say and you will win your race"…that’s wrong guys, it’s really not that easy.
Giving a few words of encouragement is ok but at least keep it realistic. Telling about personal experience is ok too…but please limit it. Don’t give out training programs if you dont know.
Even for top runners, a program may take 3 months to show any resultds..even 6 months if it’s starting from scratch.
Discuss the topic. Am I right or wrong? I will listen to you now.
So there are people out there who share my view.
Like the kid who’s taking a medication and he’s asking if he can run or not…and the answer is…give it a week or two…like really, do you know that?
I have to agree completely. The answers in this section are either very good, or very bad. College/high level runners don’t always grasp that they’re talking to kids and couch potatoes, and they give them suicidal training plans. Yes, that plan would make you an awesome runner, but realistically who could stick to it? Or, people just jump in to say "keep running, you’ll get better!" and grab 2 points for answering. Any of us who give serious answers (should) know that it really is different strokes for different folks, that the same program may not work for 2 different runners. We also should be doing too much detail work when helping someone come up with a program. But certain things really do work for almost everyone, and offering this up can be of great assistance. Any one answering (should) know that they’re talking to strangers on the internet, and that means there is no guarantee that what they’re getting is good information. In fact, anything obtained from the net should automatically send up a flag in your mind to scruitinize it heavily before accepting it.
It also angers me (a lot, thanks for letting me rant about this) when people answer just for the purpose of bashing the person’s time. These people come here looking for advice, they’re willing to share their training times with us (strangers on the net), and people will jump in just to tell them how slow they are, to tell them they suck, etc. If you were running very fast, you wouldn’t be on here asking how to get faster, now would you?
As for the encouragement, the more the better. For beginners, for kids (anyone under 20), they need to be encouraged and praised for their success, and dealt with mildly, we want them to keep looking ahead towards their goals, not get discouraged and quit. We runners tend to take for granted that there are a great many folks out there who cannot jog a mile without stopping, who aren’t in fantastic physical shape. We should encourage people who are seeking to improve themselves and are out there trying to get in shape. Beginners and young athletes sometimes need it sugar-coated, we should reserve the heavy-handed advice for the experienced runners who’ve been around and can take the straight talk.
Excellent question, by the way! I’ve enjoyed this one a great deal!